Mama Mia’s Pizza Pasta (formerly Pietro’s Oyster Bay)

So long, Pietros. La Bella left a void no pizzeria could hope to fill; yet somehow you managed. You made damn good pizza for us in OB homie, now make some for God. Rest in Peace homie.

Did this place close down for good? Terrible. I have to order from Umberto’s now which isn’t as good and is more expensive.

Went to get a few slices and the whole place is dark on a Thursday night? Hope everyone is okay

So happy I found this place! I’m new to the area. The Crustino pizza was delicious.

Best pasta in my opionion on Long Island. So sad to hear of the passing of the owner. He was so nice and always said hi when I picked up my food. Rest in piece my friend