Pottsville Pizzeria

Some of the best pizza ever now a few times we went for pizza and it seemed like there were less toppings and the onions weren't very fresh on the rest of the family's pie... but it's usually awesome so I can understand there won't always be perfect times .. And for the one who commented about them asking if they wanted baked or unbaked and thinking the pizza had to be frozen... that's not the case at all...you can have the option to have your pizza unbaked and you can bake it yourself at home and at your convenience.. They're famous for giving that option to us customers! And it's even a few bucks cheaper...!! I personally love that we can have it baked there or we can have it baked at home.. So we usually order a large baked pizza and then 2 unbaked in the same box and we'll cut chunks off and bake it when we're hungry for it.. or it could be frozen and lasts a couple months in the freezer . I'll definitely continue to give this classic pizza shop business for many years to come thank you

This is our favorite Pizza place. It's clean, cozy and the service is great. We usually get take out but will dine in once in a while.

This is the WORST PIZZA EVER!!! I ordered a pizza with light sauce and it came out with extra sauce. Now I’m SOL .No one eats sauce that heavy. The heavy set woman that worked at front counter was EXTREMELY RUDE AS HELL. I asked for light sauce she said ok and after I opened the box it had heavy sauce. She told me RUDELY THAT SHE WONT RETURN IT. Now I’m out almost 20 bucks. She also said that she couldn’t give me a refund and I told that I won’t eat it and she said that’s not my problem. Also was VERY RUDE!!! Also rolled her eyes several times. Making PISSED off faces at me and wasn’t HELPFUL AT ALL. If anything she gave us a huge ATTITUDE!!! I will not be coming again especially a ATTITUDE LIKE THAT!!! She was really unprofessional and did it in front of other customers and the other workers there too. If I could do a negative 10 on the pizza shop I would STAY AWAY FROM THE ATTITUDES

I ordered a pizza with light sauce. When the pizza was done, it was full of sauce. It turns out that they premake their pizza, so they couldn 't possibly change the amount of sauce. When I spoke with the clerk about this, she refused to issue a refund. Furthermore, she was rude and unprofessional, using phrases like I don 't care, and not my problem.

I absolutely love Pottsville Pizzeria! This place holds a special place in my heart with so many fond memories from my childhood. Whether it was enjoying a slice at the local pool, little league baseball games, or other community events, Pottsville Pizzeria was always a part of my life growing up. I try to stop by for a slice every time I pass through while living the van life, and it never disappoints. The pizza is consistently delicious, and it brings back all those nostalgic memories with each bite. I was thrilled to be in town for their 75th anniversary celebration, which was a fantastic event and a great time. The turkey sub I got on the way out was also delicious! If you're ever in Pottsville, do yourself a favor and stop by for a slice at Pottsville Pizzeria. It's a true gem that has been bringing joy to the community for decades!