Picc's Ice Cream - Old Forge

This place offers a fantastic selection of soft and hard ice cream, yogurt, and icy beverages. It's great value for the money. I've visited multiple times, and the staff has always been very friendly.

I ordered two vanilla hard ice cream milkshakes topped with whipped cream and a cherry, as well as a black raspberry milkshake with whipped cream and a cherry on top. The milkshakes were fantastic! My parents were very pleased as well.

I'm really disappointed because Piccs used to be my favorite spot for chocolate peanut butter ice cream. I came here for my birthday, and it seems like the recipe has changed because the ice cream was awful compared to what it used to be. I'm just feeling really sad and let down today. It used to be a solid 10/10 for me.

I have celiac disease and never had a problem here with the mint chocolate chip until today. While enjoying my ice cream a large chunk of what looks to be cake batter including dough was mixed into the middle of my ice cream. I stopped eating immediately but am already paying the price.

Great ice cream, has a drive through, and dog treats, always friendly