Mary Lou’s Pizza - Old Forge

Simply phenomenal pizza! They catered our last office meeting delicious.

Excellent experience! Very clean, simple menu, fantastic Old Forge pizza and great service. Highly recommend!

This is one of the Best under rated pizza places in Old forge, THE PIZZA IS AWESOME, JOE AND MARY LOU ARE THE NICEST PEOPLE YOU COULD EVE HOPE TO MEET!! ALL FOOD IS HAND MADE RIGHT THERE!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!!

I got the double crusted white broccoli, and it was delicious with the perfect amount of broccoli to cheese to crust ratio. I would definitely recommend this place.

Every time I order, I get the regular red tray. I used to rave over this pizza and have been a customer here for about two years now. The past three times I’ve had this pizza, I’ve been incredibly disappointed in the quality. Seems like it’s been either over cooked or seems like it’s old pizza that has been put back in the oven to freshen it up. Definitely lacking cheese too. I feel like if I said “light cheese”, it would be exactly what I asked for. I don’t know how much longer I’ll be a customer for which is really upsetting because it used to be my #1 go to pizza place.