Nickys Oceanport Pizza

This place no longer exists. It's been closed for several years now. To the best of my understanding, when you call here you are actually getting Olivio's in Little Silver. The site where Nicky's was located is currently the home of Gigi's which has it own Yelp page. I've notified Yelp that Nicky's is closed.

Long customer. I ordered take-out delivered by Slice. 2 Hot sandwiches, The cheese was not inside the sandwiches but o top and stuck to the aluminum foil wrapping, Very disappointing.

Oh my... where do I even begin. Let me start by saying that my boyfriend and I have present and previous experience in this industry pizza delivery, serving and hosting. We are extremely understanding people when it comes to ticket errors, food taking a while, slow service, etc. But tonight was just unacceptable as we waited for 2.5 hours for a simple pizza and two sides to be delivered. The hours of 6:45 to 9:20 consisted of a lot of calling, waiting, and messaging to figure out where the order was, if the restaurant even received the ticket in the first place, if it was out for delivery, and when to expect it. It was so ridiculous trying to track down this dang pizza. We were so looking forward to enjoying a night together, but we spent it mostly hungry, and finally disappointed. When the pizza got here it was completely cold. The wings were dry with barely any sauce on them, and they were mostly covered in black pepper. The mozzarella pinwheels were just... gross. To top it all off, they forgot our two liter of soda that we ordered. It is safe to say that we will never be ordering from here again.

Wonderful customer service and delicious thin crust Nicky’s pizza now ordered from Olivia’s!

First two times I’ve ordered from here, it was fine. The third time I placed an order, they called to cancel, no reason given. That was ridiculous but I suppose things happen. I’ve now reluctantly ordered a fourth time. After taking my payment info, my food has never arrived, and I’ve called countless times with no answer. Don’t order from these people. They shouldn’t even be in business.