Captain Jack's Seafood Market

Our go to at OIB for fresh seafood during our stay and for seafood to take home at end of our trip. Great quality and selection, farm fresh eggs and locally made key lime pie to grab for the week as well! We enjoy ceviche, tiradito and poke bowls and always find sushi grade fish we can enjoy in these dishes.

Hands up Best Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes! They are made there and they are fabulous. I lightly browned them in The Olive Press Meyer Lemon EVOO.

Waited literally an hour before our food was served but the 2 young people serving were super bz. Food was ok, but the crab cakes were not cooked through so we couldn’t eat and didn’t want to wait another hour to have more cooked! The sweet potato is not a sweet potato .. it’s some gunk in a bowl in a nasty sauce: but in all fairness the seafood was ok!

This place is a must stop for sea food. Great selection, super friendly staff.

Love Captain Jacks, easy to get in, out great selection always fresh