Woodcroft Steakhouse Seafood - Nutley

I had a fantastic experience at this restaurant. The service was outstanding, and the ribeye steak was exceptional – dry-aged, buttery, tender, and cooked to perfection as ordered. The creamed spinach was delicious, and the beet salad was fresh, making for a great appetizer. The cocktails were very creative and well-prepared, especially the Tiki Italia. The staff was attentive and worked together seamlessly to provide a top-notch experience. While it can get a bit loud, the ambiance is beautifully romantic. Overall, the quality of the food is excellent for a fair price.

Our first experience was excellent. The quality of the steak was outstanding, although it could have benefited from a bit more seasoning. The side dishes were good, but not exceptional. We will definitely be returning to this restaurant, which has a fantastic atmosphere.

The food was good, but the afterthought was that there was only one toilet for women and men. the restaurant held at least 100 or more people, but there was only one toilet room. will not return.

Our second time here hoping it would be better. It’s the only steakhouse in town. It was extremely loud and hard to talk. The drinks were ok. The service was slow. They need a person to clean the tables in between servings. Tuna tartare was tasty but served with no chip or pita. The filet mignon lacked seasoning. The ribeye is tough and lack of salt. Their homemade steak sauce was water downed. Their chocolate mousse cake tasted old grainy and frozen. The cappuccino lacked caffeine and served extremely light with no sugar or cinnamon. Our bill was $220. Not worth it!

I had high hopes for my sons 25th birthday celebration after reading the reviews, but the steaks were not good, and calamari was rubbery. They tried very hard, the service and setting were good, they were very friendly and accommodating, but the food needs work.