Nutley Bagel Boy

Good sized sandwiches, with generous portions. The coffee however, was only average, and was definitely in need of change, having been a bit overlong in the dispenser. One thing I noticed however, and this should be a caveat for customers. I observed MAJOR PRICE INCONSISTENCIES BETWEEN WHAT WAS LISTED ON THE MENU BOARD AND THE PRICES FOR THOSE ITEMS ON MY RECEIPT. This is clearly a red flag for anyone coming in. Check your receipt after looking at the menu boards carefully.This place could have been so much higher rated in my book if not for this severe financial faux pas.

I used to love this place. There bagels are decent and I used to like them a lot. Now i’m not allowed in at all. According to the workers i’m banned however I have not been in the country for the last week. The worker is violent and got very confrontational with me and my friend. I’m not sure if he understands english but him and his co workers are nothing but rude and disrespectful. There service is slow and there prices are a little high. I would love to go there but i can’t. There are much better options in nutley such as spankies and amore. I’m sad to say the my previously favorite bagel place in nutley is no longer my favorite.

It sucks food was very bad and the workers were very rude. They kicked me out and lied saying I was yelling.

This place has very very good quality , tasty Bagels but also egg and cheese on a roll, home fries, sandwiches, coffee Menu.. you can dine in they have lots of seating or take out.. it’s super super clean and service is top class. Tucked away in beautiful NJ burb and perfect for Bagel fans.. gonna be a repeat Customer..

I have not been here for YEARS the previous owner was Mike. He was an awesome guy who knew everyone and all the kids loved him! He would like my order on charge and my grandmother would pay monthly lol those were the days!