Stella's Pizzeria - Newburgh

I've been meaning to post here but I came to this location about two weeks go an ordered two penne ala vodka meals around a hour before closing. I got off a long shift and was staring but if i wasn't i likely would've brought it back the next day. The pastawas beyond dry and had NO FLAVOR WHATSOEVR. the only saving grace was me adding parm cheese and ranch dressing LOL. its funny inhindsight but i was extremely extremely unhappy

Amazing! Food and service were great! I wasn’t surprised to learn that there’s a real, culinary trained chef behind it. I first went with my son and then returned with my sister and they both loved it — the pizza was delicious, the salmon salad, the meatballs too! And my son loved the chicken sandwich. No matter what you choose, you won’t be disappointed! Thanks Chef Mike for such great food. I’ll be back soon.

Went for dinner today with my family and i must say the BEST food we ever had. Everything was made to perfection. The portions were huge and the prices were amazing. Will definitely be back. The owner is a real chef the food speaks for itself!! Amazing Amazing!!

I have been to Stella's with my family several times since its grand opening. Each time we've eaten there, the pizza and dinners have been consistently delicious and made with the finest ingredients. The presentation of the dinners are above and beyond a pizzeria and more like a nice Italian restaurant. The prices are extremely reasonable and Mike the owner and his staff are very friendly.

Came to check it out since it changed ownership. I tried their pancetta w/ egg slice, and it was delicious! Very good pizza. The staff was friendly... will be back again to try some pasta.