Rosemary's Cafe And Pizzeria - Newburgh

Best and most affordable pizza in Newburgh. Owned by great hard working people from the City of Newburgh.

I’ve had a frustrating experience with my DoorDash orders. They never confirm them, and now there’s a hold on my account due to a canceled order.

I ordered a medium pizza through DoorDash and ended up waiting over an hour only to have my order canceled—not by the restaurant, but by the dasher. If you can’t fulfill an order, at least take the initiative to cancel it yourself so customers aren't left waiting for so long. This is a poor and lazy business practice. Also, it's puzzling how a restaurant can be out of a menu item when it’s literally in their name and they still have hours until closing. Disappointing experience.

On my second visit, I ordered the steak and eggs, and the steak was perfectly seasoned. I requested it medium, and it came out just right, cooked perfectly in the center. I will definitely be coming back for the steak and eggs; they have become my favorite dish on the menu. This place is family-owned, and you can truly taste the love that goes into the food. I'm so happy to have this amazing new local spot!

I absolutely love this restaurant! They offer amazing dishes and have a wide-ranging menu. The chef here is truly a professional, and I really enjoy trying each of their creations. The food is consistently high quality, and the service is always friendly. I dine here regularly and have never been disappointed. I highly recommend this place!