Eddie's Gourmet Pizza - Newburgh

Eddie's Gourmet Pizza really came through for me! I placed a last-minute order for my daughter's birthday and Eddie was incredibly helpful and polite on the phone. I ordered four pizzas, wings, meatballs, and sausage, and everything was absolutely delicious. The meatballs were a standout! When I realized I couldn't pick up the order the next day, I called two hours before the party to see if they could deliver, and they were able to accommodate. The delivery person was friendly and helpful, even offering to assist with anything else I needed. Eddie's will definitely be my go-to for any future parties!

Everyone in town knows about this place. Unfortunately, it is run by older men who are not up to par. Some, like my family, refuse to go there anymore. The food is absolutely disgusting. We gave it another chance today, but my wife's wrap was full of chicken fat and had to be thrown away. My salad was ice cold, flavorless, undercooked, and looked like it came out of a can. It was drowning in watery ranch dressing. Terrible. The only saving grace was the two teenagers working there, who were around 16 years old. They were the only ones working hard.

I am writing a review for this establishment because it truly is a fantastic pizza joint! The only downside is that Eddie's doesn't offer delivery before 2:00, but despite this minor inconvenience, Eddie's is a great spot for delicious food and excellent customer service. I highly recommend their pizza to anyone in or around the area. (Reviewer) (Rating)

In the rule one of the best but Saturdays do not waste their time or money .dont know who they are in this kitchen, but they could have 2 fs about what comes out of this door, undercooked pizza and the most disgusting wings I have ever had.

I have say that other people love other places for pizza but for a pretty good sausage and pepper pie, asap, you can't beat Eddie's. The problem with the chains is that everything is so precisely measured and controlled that if they give you an extra slice of sausage on your pie they throw off the corporation's bottom line for a year. Hence everything is shaved and nickeled and dimed. Eddie's isn't like that and the people are nice. In short, a good place to go and they deliver.