The Brass Rail - New York

We came to Brass Rail on a Friday night and had a great time. We sat at the bar and the bartender Allie was super hospitable. We ordered oysters (super fresh! a variety of small plates, some salads and three different deserts and everything, absolutely everything was excellent. The place is really cozy and not too loud, something that is important to me after a long work week. We will absolutely be back for home made ice cream. I can't wait to try everything on the menu.

Excellent atmosphere, staff is pleasant, the food is amazing!

We've usually visited this restaurant for a number of years whenever we drive up from Brooklyn to visit this area. The food and service have always been good. This Columbus day we stopped by for lunch but were surprised to wait nearly 30 minutes before our main order came out, after we expressed our concern to our waiter. He never apologized and in fact served several other customers who came in after us, before our dishes arrived. Incidentally, one of the dishes was only lukewarm. This inatten … – show

Don’t go if you have a food allergy of any kind. There chef is clearly untrained and served contaminated food to my wife. She has spent the last 24 hours throwing up and sick from the gluten that was in her food. The server said this would be no problem to accommodate but obviously the kitchen is not professionally trained in this area. Food in general is average.

Service not great, meal not great — peach cobbler horrible. Pass on this place