Petee's Pie Company - New York

The portion of ice cream is very small. When compared to a regular pint, it is noticeably smaller. The pie portions are also small for the price. However, the Wild Maine Blueberry Slice was truly one of the best slices of pie I have ever had. I would order it again, but I do wish the portions were larger as it feels a bit overpriced.

The strawberry rhubarb slice was delicious! I will definitely buy a whole pie next time. However, the rhubarb streusel was not as good. I enjoyed the tartness of the rhubarb, but the crust was overly sweet and didn't complement the rhubarb well.

Petee's is the go-to spot for delicious pies! I always go for the Key Lime Slice and it never disappoints. I appreciate that they offer both lemon and lime options. The Cherry Crumb Slice has a flavorful filling with a hint of spices. Trying the Eggnog Cheesecake Slice for the first time was a memorable experience. Petee's nails it with their crumb crusts and the cheesecake texture was perfect - firm yet creamy. The flavor of the cheesecake was absolutely scrumptious, even though I couldn't really taste the eggnog.

The Salty Chocolate Chess Slice was delicious but the Black Bottom Almond Chess Slice had a bit of a raw alcohol taste which I did not want (from the amaretto). But otherwise the Black Bottom Almond Chess Slice was a good flavor. My family takes our southern sweet potato recipe very seriously so I was disappointed in the Sweet Potato Slice , it tasted almost savory to me and I couldn't identify any sweet potato flavor so I was just confused a bit by the taste.

LOVE Peetee's Pies! Especially the cream pies and the crumb pies. Highly recommended!