One if by Land, Two if by Sea

Overall, the ambience was not overly romantic as advertised. The service was slow and not attentive Long wait to be served wine and had to ask to get a menu. Generally, the food was good but not spectacular. Not recommended for a romantic dinner for two.

This is without question our favorite restaurant in New York City and a place we always love going to. Service was impeccable and the chef always does an amazing job . The cocktail, called the oldest old-fashioned, is one of the best I’ve ever had and the chocolate soufflé is definitely worth the wait!

Love it, very special dinner, delicious food with good portions, amazing service!

Did not disappoint. I have been there several times in my life but not in a long time I have wanted to bring my wife for years I finally said we are going! We brought another couple that had never been either Everything was perfect! Fernando was awesome as was the rest of the staff! And of course, the WELLINGTON!! Thank you OIBL TIBS!!!!!

A “Gem” in the middle of lower Manhattan. Being that I’m a big fan of John Gotti, it was fitting to have dinner at this fabulous restaurant because this was his favorite restaurant according to his daughter, Angel. And in true fashion, we were not disappointed one bit. The ambience is absolutely spectacular and very romantic. We ate from the three course meal menu and everything was absolutely delicious. I highly recommend this place. Thank you, Angel Gotti for letting us know that this was one of your dad’s favorite restaurant in all of Manhattan.