Caked Up Cafe - New City

Caked up provided a three trier cake for our wedding last week. So many people said it was the best cake they’d ever had!! Not only was the cake delicious but when we went to the shop for our tasting the owner couldn’t have been more sweet or generous. What an amazing place!

Caked Up, you've truly exceeded our expectations once again! We came to you with a unique challenge: a cake shaped like a brick that holds significant sentimental value in our heritage. And you absolutely nailed it! Not only did the cake look just like a brick, but it was also the most delicious "brick" we've ever had. The three layers of vanilla cake with Dulce de Leche filling were a perfect combination. The flavors blended beautifully, creating a taste experience that left everyone amazed. The photo doesn't even begin to capture the incredible craftsmanship and mouthwatering goodness of this cake. Thank you, Caked Up, for transforming our seemingly impossible idea into a culinary masterpiece. You made our family reunion an unforgettable occasion, and we are so grateful for your talent and dedication!

The cookies here are amazing! The staff is incredibly sweet and kind, providing excellent customer service. I'm visiting from California and decided to stop by because of the fantastic reviews. The treats are delicious, and I highly recommend this place!

This is my favorite dessert place! I always order the strawberry cheesecake cupcake, and it never lets me down. Everyone in the shop is incredibly friendly, and I want to give a special shoutout to Brendan and Sam for consistently going above and beyond. I absolutely love it here!

Love Caked Up! My personal fave is the strawberry shortcake cupcake! The taste of the various sweets is what got me in the door, but what has kept me as a consistent customer is the customer service! There has been a time or two that I’ve come and they were out of my fave— strawberry shortcake, and each time, the staff happily accommodated my request! And more importantly, another personal fave are two particular staff, Sam Brendan who recognize me, know my order when I come in, and are so kind! Oh, and lastly, they have dog-friendly treats, daily! So when I get something, so does my pup. It’s a win, win! Thanks Caked Up, “see you in two weeks!”