Barbaro - Millbrook

The food was really well done. It is Italian. But has a Greek name. Hugh Food: 4 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 3

We absolutely adored this restaurant! Everything was wonderful...we sat at the bar and Olivia was an excellent bartender and host. The grilled octopus starter was amazing and the seafood pasta was perfectly spicy and delicious. The chocolate torte was perfection. The service was great. We dined for dinner and paid $50-$100 per person. The food, service, and atmosphere all deserve a 5-star rating. We highly recommend trying the Grilled Octopus.

We arrived at 5 pm with reservations. We asked for bread and were informed that there was no complimentary bread available, but we could order rosemary oven roasted bread for $18. Unfortunately, the bread lacked flavor and was similar to a cracker that did not absorb oil well. Other guests who arrived after us received their meals 25 minutes before we received ours, which arrived an hour and five minutes after we arrived. Despite having visited this restaurant several times before, we are uncertain if we will return in the future. Our waitress was attentive, but overall, the experience was disappointingly poor. The service was rated a 3, the food a 2, and the atmosphere a 2. This was a dine-in dinner with a price range of $50-100 per person.

We sat outside on a cold night, but were kept warm by the lovely gas heaters that felt like giant candles. We shared a delicious kale salad and a wood-fired pizza. It was perfect! I absolutely adore this restaurant. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Best restaurant in NYC Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5