Amici Italian Grill - Middletown

Wonderful spot for a good Italian meal. My friends and family really enjoyed the food, the atmosphere and the friendly service.

This is our favorite Italian restaurant! My husband and I have been going for years with and without the kids. The servers are always so inviting and friendly, and most importantly the food never disappoints! My favorite part is that there are always leftovers from the generous portions to bring home and enjoy the next day.

It was incredible! We arrived two hours earlier than our reservation, and the staff treated us wonderfully! The food was fantastic. We will definitely return and recommend it to everyone!

I visited Amici during the recent holiday season and had a disappointing experience, which prompted me to leave a negative review on this page. However, the management saw my feedback and kindly sent me a gift card, for which I am truly grateful. I quickly removed my negative review after that. Last night, I returned with my girlfriend, and I realized that our first visit must have been an exception because our experience this time was fantastic. We started with the calamari appetizer, which was absolutely a 10. For our main course, we both ordered steak and spinach. The steaks were lean and cooked to perfection, while the spinach was flavorful and served piping hot. Thank you once again for the gift card; we will definitely be returning!

There are many excellent restaurants in Middletown, but Amici's is my favorite by far. Outstanding in every way.