Goodfella's - McCordsville

My first time there I clicked on check in and got a messages for 20% off my first order. I showed it to the server who told me that wasn 't their store as we don 't have a 20% off key. She refused to honor the yelp coupon so I got up and walked out. The owner was not there on Taft Sunday evening. I made several calls the next week but the owner was not there. I left my cell number on my last call and never did the owner call me. I am pretty sure this is illegal in my state. I can 't find a way to inform Yelp of this situation. Never going back.

If you like brick oven pizza then you have got to try the old world style pizza. My family loves the the plain with sauce and fresh mozzarella. The sauce is amazing and the crust is nice and thin. We don't live close by so when we do make it here it is a treat. We literally get 3 large pizzas to go and we demolish them. I have sat down at this place before but it has been a while. They have a full bar and I remember the salads and lobster bisque being tasty.

We recently moved to Indiana and this is our second time eating here, its just down the street. Food is yummy Stephanie U served us tonite, she was very nice friendly! Hubby got the chicken fettuccine alfredo I got my beloved cheese ravioli. Its was super yum! The alfredo sauce has a nice flavor the cheese in ravioli had a really great flavor! We got the sampler app as we never really ate here wanted to try everything. I loved the wings hubby loved the fried ravioli! They use fresh motz for the fried cheese is to die for! Goodfellas is our new Italian spot close by our house! PS the young man taking our plates was such a sweet young man! Thank you for making everything yummy!

Pizza is great when cooked right. It's been very inconsistent lately. This is a picture of a Well Done traditional pizza. Cheese is barely melted.

Service and quality just aren't good enough for me to want to go here. In fairness I've only been there 3 times, but it's only 5 mins from my house and I probably won't go back.