Mary's Diner - McConnellsville

My family made the drive out to Mary's this summer as we'd heard nothing but good things about the breakfast here. Mary's is about 5 minutes outside of downtown Sylvan Beach, so easy to get to for locals or vacationers to Oneida Lake. We were seated quickly when we arrived around 8:30 on a Saturday, and were glad to get there when we did as it filled up quickly just after we got our table. Patrons have the choice of booths, tables, or up at the counter just how a diner should be. My wife ordered the pancakes and sausage while I opted for the 3 egg breakfast (sunny side up, always) with some bacon and rye toast. My wife raved about her pancakes and was able to get sugar free syrup with her meal. Portions were generous and food came out quickly. Our waitress was friendly and kept drink refills of water, juice, and coffee rolling. Prices are reasonable and the menu was quite large. Lunch is also available and we'd love to come out and try that sometime. Mary's succeeds in what makes a good diner worth driving to. My only drawback would be the wait to get a table on the weekend if you arrive at the wrong time. It was standing room only when we left.

We enjoyed Mary's Diner very much. We went 3 times when in the area and food was great and our server was very accommodating. He let us have our dog outside on the patio and even got him some water and a slice of bacon. We went for lunch and didn't realize they were closing in 15 minutes. They still took care of us with a smile. We will definitely be back for the great food and friendly people!!

Great little old school diner. The staff was very friendly and there was a lot of seating for the size of their dining area. The menu was small but had all the breakfast classics. I ordered an eggs and hashbrowns plate, short stack of pancakes, and a cup of coffee. The bill was only $10 amazing in this day and age! If you find yourself in the area, stop by for breakfast or lunch. They are open 7am 3pm daily.

Incredible food. We are From Maine and were on the way to Pulaski and used Yelp to find this gem. All the reviews were well deserved 5 stars except for one KAREN who seems to be very unhappy in life. After reading her review I had to try the sausage gravy and it was piping hot! Every staff member wears welcoming and checked back after we took our first bites to make sure we were happy. Wish we had a place like this in Maine!!!

This is the number 1 best place to get breakfast. Well cooked food with a friendly atmosphere. You get your monies worth in this place. Stop in for lunch too. You will not be disappointed