Osteria Matarello - Markham

The food is fantastic! The portion sizes are more generous than they initially appear.

Regarding the food, I found that about 25% of the 10 oz steak was fat. While the steak was a bit on the salty side, the sauce was enjoyable. The potatoes were cooked to a nice crispness. Normally, I fill up quickly, but due to the excess fat that I avoided and the relatively small portion size, I felt hungry again shortly after dinner. We arrived half an hour early, at 5:30 PM, and there was only one other small group dining, so it was quite quiet. Overall, I was disappointed with both the value and taste of the food, especially since I have a fondness for Italian cuisine. It didn’t leave me with a “wow” impression, and I don’t think I’ll return. However, I am glad I tried this restaurant.

I had an incredible experience at this restaurant! I've dined here several times, and it never fails to impress. The mushroom truffle Mafalda is absolutely the best!

Not happy at all with the service that I received from the girl there. She was the only server there and she said she is the general manager. My first experience in this location, the salad and pizza were excellent and very delicious, Calamari was awesome. Food was very very good. I hope if I try this restaurant in the future, the girl be on her day off.

Celebrated a quiet and delicious dinner on my birthday and couldn’t have asked for better service. Our server was very attentive, witty yet polite.