Buttercooky Bakery - MANHASSET

If you want a surprise for your wedding cake , this is the bakery to order from! We specifically stated what flavors we wanted for the filling, and the color of the decorative flowers on the cake. Both were COMPLETELY WRONG, and we reached out multiple times with NO REPLY. Thank god the wedding was memorable because the Cake surely wasn?t. Very disappointed in you guys for getting both the inside and outside of cake incorrect. Oh, and not to mention the cake price

May have had one of the best cookies ever! (But I?m a huge fan of white chocolate). Delicious pastries

NOT FRESH An average bakery, with a sizable area for sit down. I?ve bought their cookies in the past (at least a decade) and remembered they were good. Both cakes are old: Tiramisu isn't too sweet which I like (Iavarone Bros? is better) and cheese cake is so so too, not even close to Veniero?s Pasticceria Caffe on 11th Street in the city. My complaint is all their displays have no price. Ok I get it, people go there either regulars who don?t need to know or the wealthy

Delicious the Fresh Fruit Tart , the Tres Leche Bowl, Raspberry Macaron and NY Cheesecake pastry

I normally patronize Jericho Turnpike. I found this location by accident and I was not disappointed. TEN STARS