Harbour Fish - Mamaroneck

Craving Oysters and just picked this place on a whim to try when I googled fresh oysters. Drove by it a million times and never noticed since it’s not on the busy Mamaroneck strip. It actually has additional parking in back. I would call this a hidden gem because you can easily overlook it due to the location and lack of curb presence. We had the Prix Fixe menu which was quite good value for three courses. Oysters were great. We finished it too quickly before I remembered to take pictures. My Snapper was fantastic. The Branzino was very good but should have ordered the whole fish rather than fillet. The rum cake was delicious and reminded me of Tres Leche instead of the Caribbean variety. Cheesecake was excellent and better than the key lime. The latter a bit too sweet where as we preferred a sharper lime taste. They brought us the wrong one so we got to try both. There is a Latin flavor to the dishes and not your typical southern deep fried seafood shack. It’s clean and pleasant but a bit of thoughtful decorations might give it more atmosphere. The owners can either try more festive or more romantic. Not sure which way I would go. The food and service are definitely excellent. Will come back again.

First time trying this place, pictures looked amazing, food LOOKED AMAZING. ZERO TASTE, zero flavor. First off, ordered a side of spaghetti which was $15!!! Noodles were covered in butter water, cup of sauce tasted canned with a splash of someone’s cologne.Ordered salmon, again, looked beautiful, missing lemon, salt, a dash of any seasoning.Never in my life had a fried shrimp that tasted like nothing, it didn’t even taste like oil! And to top it off, food was cold. And no, we did not pick it up late, we got there and still had to wait for the food.

Delicious food and great service an excellent experience! Plan to return again soon!

Service great, food average. I wouldn't be quick to go back.

Great whole fried red snapper. Oysters did not look or taste right so they took off check. Service was attentive and friendly. Nice bright space.