Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Madison

The food is fantastic, and the atmosphere is wonderful! This has become my new favorite sandwich shop in Wisconsin!

The tuna and wreck sandwiches were both excellent. However, the prices are a bit high for a sandwich shop. After spending five years in Louisiana, it was a pleasant surprise to find Zapp's potato chips available. Unfortunately, the soda fountain didn't offer any clear sodas like Sprite or Sierra Mist, and there was no option for unsweetened tea. I would definitely return, as the staff was extremely friendly during our first visit.

This was the best sandwich I've ever had that wasn't made at home. It was flavorful, warm, and all-around fantastic. The mac and cheese was even more impressive—rich and cheesy, especially with the complimentary addition of bacon and mushrooms. I highly recommend it!

I was shopping with a friend we were talking about our favorite sandwiches. I told her, nothing beats a BLT with some avocado. Guess what was the special? It was a sign. The bacon is cut nice thick and it gets cooked perfectly! Loved it!

I've been in Madison for years and this location routinely delivers quality service and food. Even when they're slammed, sandwiches come out nicely. They don't skimp, and they are efficient. On some of my crappiest work days, I've stopped here for lunch, and they've made it a bit better. This is my favorite location in Madison. Thank you!