Farmer's Creekside Tavern Inn - Le Roy

Okay, so this is NOT a bed breakfast in the normal sense... just a room on the other side of the restaurant. It is a very nice room but you do get some noise at night from the bar next door. There is no downstairs sitting area and the opportunity to meet and talk with the owners. That part is missing more like a hotel room. The ambiance we nice with a view of the creek. The food was okay... but not worth the money. The french onion soup with gruyere cheese was very bland... I would not order again. The steak was good but tasted more like a pot roast. The cookie dessert plate was a variety but all were very hard (if you like that kind). All in all, nice but more of a one time and done...

I find it difficult to leave a negative review, but when asked for my opinion, I believe in honesty. The ambiance of this restaurant is exceptional. They have really thought of everything and left no detail undone. We stayed at the Inn for Valentine's Day and dined in the dining room. The staff was excellent. However, my disappointment came with the food. The Valentine's Day menu was preset with limited options at a steep price of $65.00 per person. I ordered the buttermilk chicken, which was dry and unappetizing. My husband's filet was small and came with only two pieces of asparagus. This did not feel like a $65.00 per person meal. I wish we could have ordered items from the regular menu, as it would have made the experience much better. Spending $130.00 on a meal that did not meet our expectations was disappointing. Despite this, we plan to return to try items from the regular menu, as the restaurant is a lovely spot in Leroy.

My wife and I have been to Farmer's a number of times, usually inviting along friends or family. This was the first time we were disappointed with the food. The portions (scallop preparation) for the price was surprising. My wife had the butternut squash bisque (okay) and the beet salad (mostly greens and very light on beets or additions/toppings). It was the first time for the couple we invited along and they were impressed, as we are, with the atmosphere, service and décor but questioned the value. I will add that I know my wife and I will be back. We have been very satisfied many times and feel this was probably just a single experience.

Great ambiance and bartender was very friendly and helpful. Waitress was wonderful when we had to ask about which foods were fairy free. Delicious food. A fantastic overall experience! What a gem in LeRoy, NY!

We have had excellent experiences with the food and service at Farmer's Creekside each of the three times we have dined there. We highly recommend it. While it may not be cheap, the prices seem to be justified by the high quality.