Bonny's Pizzeria - Lake Ronkonkoma

The service was outstanding. I visited on New Year's Eve after traveling from overseas, and it truly satisfied my craving. The chicken pesto pizza is absolutely delicious!

While I don’t usually make a special trip to this place, I’m definitely planning to return, though I’m not sure when. Like most people, I love pizza, but I wouldn’t place this restaurant among my top 10 favorites just yet. I often hang out near Portion Road, but I usually try other eateries in the area. I’d rate the regular slice a 4/10, but the grandma slice easily deserves a 10/10. If you visit, make sure to try the grandma slice!

THE BEST PIZZA ON LONG ISLAND THAT I'VE FOUND!!! From the first glance to the first bite, it’s absolutely amazing. Both of my parents were born and raised in Italy, so they take their pizza very seriously, as do I. The crust is so good, it’s even better than my grandma's Pasta Fasulo. And believe me, that's saying something! The way ANDIAMO'S prepares their pizza is simply divine—truly heavenly. The chef's skills rival those of Gordon Ramsay. So remember, fam, when you eat, make sure you do it right!

I love their pizza its my favorite. And the wings too. But last week I order pizza and wings but the wings were so bad they were not fresh, so hard and barely had any sauce on them they tasted like they were left over or from a previously canceled order. I figured this may have been a one time thing, so the next weekend, I go back just for the pizza, and even though it was ordered ahead of time, they said that the cook didn't receive the ticket, so I wound up waiting 45 minutes for a cheese pizza that wasn't even fully cooked!

This is our favorite pizza place! Nothing we have had from here has been bad. Obviously the pizza is why we order primarily BUT their menu is great. We tried out their wings tonight and enjoyed them. Highly recommend. ??