Liberty Prime Steakhouse - Jersey City

Was very disappointed in a steak house that served us bad, very tough steaks. 2 of our table of 4 ordered the NY Strip, a cut I've enjoyed at dozens of places. Not just one, but both our steaks looked good, but we had to saw our way through them. Just tough and not terribly flavorful meat. The sides were also just ok, lobster mac and cheese had very little lobster, etc. Our server was lovely though. But due a place that holds itself out as a prime steakhouse, was very disappointing. I will not return.

It was insane how empty it was on a Saturday night and just how straight up bad the service was. It really doesn’t make sense to have the waiter as the bartender, the busser and the server. Steak was cooked with no seasoning, brussels sprouts no flavor, fries nothing, mashed potatoes just a blob on the plate. Not to mention the unnerving pale brown and pink color the meat was when it was served “fresh”. When we arrived we were taken to our table, no menus, the candle that was there was spilled over all over the tablecloth (no one cared i guess). We sat for about 10 mins unattended. Finally someone comes and says Hi and brings water and then is replaced by another guy?? Honestly just an all around terrible experience. Save your money and go to Ruth’s Chris!

The ambiance was great. Food was great! 10/10! The Bartenders were super nice and my waiter James was very attentive and professional. But the hostess at the front couldn’t get her name but she has blonde hair , She was very rude and unprofessional.

The service and ambience were both wonderful. I will be calling the restaurant because I believe we were overcharged- I really hope we were overcharged.

Prix fixe menu was not advertised and was overpriced. Decided to leave due to lack of options.