Your Pie - Jacksonville

I noticed a packed parking lot at the new Your Pie on Beach and Hodges, so I assumed they were open for business. Upon entering, I was warmly greeted and learned it was actually a soft opening. Even though my name wasn’t on the list, they welcomed me inside. As I moved through the pizza assembly line, the enthusiastic rookie chefs generously piled on my chosen sauce, cheese, and toppings. I grabbed a drink cup and filled it with ice, only to discover the sweet tea was completely out—just a slow drip from the spigot. When I asked if there was more, the answer was no. So, I settled for water and sat down to enjoy my handcrafted pizza. Just five minutes later, a manager approached my table with a cup and said, "Let me know how that tastes." It turned out to be perfectly southern sweet tea—made by a New Yorker! Kudos to Your Pie at Beach and Hodges…great job!

They offer a variety of options, including salads and customizable pizzas. You can choose from different types of bread for your pizza, such as gluten-free, Panini, and various kids' options. The sauces available are fantastic, including marinara, extra virgin olive oil, buffalo sauce, BBQ, and delicious pesto. You can choose from a wide selection of cheeses like shredded mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, provolone, and vegan cheese. The toppings are extensive too! You can add pepperoni, bacon, chicken, Italian sausage, meatballs, ham, turkey, salami, as well as a variety of veggies like artichokes, banana peppers, basil, black olives, broccoli, cilantro, garlic, green bell peppers, jalapeños, mushrooms, oregano, pineapple, red onions, romaine, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, and fresh tomatoes. To top it off, there are plenty of dressings to choose from, including balsamic vinegar, blue cheese, Caesar, Greek, ranch, and jalapeño honey mustard. Everything was just delicious, and I highly recommend visiting Your Pie to experience the wonderful flavors they offer!

I relocated to Jacksonville two years ago from New York, a place famous for its amazing pizza! Until 'Your Pie' opened, I struggled to find a decent pizza in JAX. Their thin crust is crispy and absolutely delicious! This place is a must-try, and the staff were exceptionally friendly and helpful. Congratulations and best wishes to them!

Just had the most delicious pizza at Your Pie. So many items to choose from and gelato for dessert. Wait staff are so accommodating. I'd recommend it to everyone. Reasonably priced, too. Grand Opening is Friday, May 12th.

Loved Your Pie! I tried it for the first time last night and was pleasantly surprised by how fresh the ingredients tasted and how fast my pizza came out. I tried the whole wheat crust and it was delicious! The owner/manager came up to our table and was very helpful and friendly as was all the staff. They even have gelato which looked amazing. Didn't try it on this visit but definitely will on the next.