New Berlin Fish House And Oyster

Came in on my lunch break alone, sat at the bar and Ashley treated me like VIP! My food and service were superb! I will definitely go back.

I visited with my family, and my server, Abby, was exceptional. She was very attentive and offered great suggestions. I had my one-year-old daughter and my newborn with me, and the staff made sure we were accommodated comfortably. Kayla, the manager on duty, genuinely showed care for my family and ensured we were at ease. When my one-year-old started to fuss, Kayla kindly asked us what she liked to watch. I was at a loss for words, but Kayla quickly found something kid-friendly on TV, which worked wonders! I've never experienced that level of thoughtfulness before. I will definitely continue to support this business. Thank you so much, Abby, for your wonderful service. Kayla, your exceptional managerial skills are truly appreciated!

Kid-friendliness: The kids' menu had a great variety, and the waitress was very patient with our little ones.

THEY DO NOT SERVE ALCOHOL! Although they have a liquor license, they are unable to serve drinks due to capacity restrictions. They also lack the ingredients for non-alcoholic beverages. The food was average; the fish lacked flavor, but the gator tail was excellent. The sides—including green beans, collard greens, and sweet potato fries—were quite tasteless. Overall, I would not recommend this place!

Second time here. Had the fried snapper and it was delicious! Happy hour has half off wine/single shot drinks/draft beers so we took advantage of it. Abby was our server and she was attentive and took great care of us. Will definitely be back.