New York Bagel Co - Islandia

Best bagels in the world and their food is delicious

Ordered 2 eggs on roll bacon and cheese. Got scrambled eggs on a plain bagel with bacon and cheese. Ordered 2 everything and a plain bagel did not receive the plain bagel.

I 10/10 recommend this place. The Hispanic young lady that took my order was super friendly my order was accurate and swift. They also have reasonable pricing and I actually really enjoyed my breakfast sandwich. I went completely out of my way to get here after experiencing poor service from a closer bagel store and you guys did not disappoint. Thank you!

I love the bagels here I used to go everyday since I work so close but then they started getting new people and I kept getting charged wrong well months have gone by so I figured I would try again. Yesterday when I got there I ordered a bagel with cream cheese and a juice it came to $6 and change well today I go in an order the exact same thing and was charged $10.21 I didn't even realize until I left. Very disappointed. I understand they need staff but they shouldn't run register if they don't know how to charge.

The young ladies working the front counter couldn’t have been friendlier when taking my order. The food was made quickly and tasted AMAZING! 10/10 would recommend and I’ll definitely be coming back in the near future.