Pier 48 Fish House Oyster Bar Downtown INDY

Service was good and really enjoyed the atmosphere. Did not eat dinner but had a salad (which was good) and a bunch of oysters. The oyster selection was good and pricing was about what you would think in the Midwest. I would go back.

Service slow. Took forever to clear plates. Waitress not around much

The food is decent, but the experience leaves much to be desired. We first went there one night for oysters, and had an awful experience. I received a survey by email, and outlined the issues privately. This led to us being invited to a private menu release party, and we had a good enough time there that I later reached out to plan a personal, private, surprise celebration. Getting the details pinned down wasn 't as easy as I would have liked it to be, and the day before, I got a text message the evening before stating that the cake ordered from their vendor is not carrot, but a very beautiful vanilla butter cake and said that they hope that will be okay. I was never given a reason, or offered any discounts even thought it was literally 17 hours before the party was scheduled. Since it was so close to the time, and it was a surprise party, I couldn 't exactly show up with my own cake, so I just said that 's fine what else could I have done for the dessert option? The event went really well, my family had a great time, and the server who worked the event was amazing. However, the cake was definitely not worth the $55 +tax I was charged. Furthermore, the restaurant 's points system feel like a scam. The automatic points did not match based on what I paid the day of (464 points awarded for a $431 balance), and when I reached out to ask about the additional points for the $200 deposit I put on the party, I was told that I had points (not helpful at all). I clarified that it should be $631 points total, and have been ghosted ever since. I don 't doubt that is because if I got the points I am actually owed since it 's 1 point per $1, I would be immediately owed a $50 reward. The tl;dr is if you have the money, and want seafood, go to Oceanaire instead. They have never given us a headache.

Devour Indy was a great deal. The food was very good. The overall experience was great. The mahi mahi was very good.

I stopped in for 'devour Indy ' at lunch and although they were out of my first choice. They let me graze beyond the fixed menu> I had the trout which was plentiful in size and well prepared. The Crab Beignets were awesome! And the Crème Brule was quite good. I also enjoyed a glass of wine and some west coast oysters.