1653 Pizza Company - Huntington

We had a wonderful experience at this restaurant. The food was exceptional, far surpassing what you'd typically find at a pizzeria. It feels more like a true Italian restaurant. The pistachio dessert was absolutely outstanding. The drink menu also featured a variety of intriguing options. To our pleasant surprise, the music was fantastic as well.

I wasn't impressed with the new menu. I feel like there are limited choices.

This is a fantastic spot for upscale pizza. The pear salad is incredible. I'm already looking forward to my next visit to sample more items from the menu. There's also some really nice live entertainment.

The food was outstanding started with the Cesar salad and split three pizzas among four adults. Had the affogato, gelato ice cream sandwich and pistachio dessert. Loved the affogato and ice cream sandwich not a huge fan on the pistachio. The one downfall…it’s LOUD. Either loud piped in music or a musician (who was very good) but LOUD to the point where our waitress couldn’t hear us trying to get her attention

Reservation was honored for 6 people at 7:00. Waitress was really good. We ordered drinks (fabulous) and appetizers…..fried baby artichokes, mini cheese, olives and toasted almonds, fried calamari and shrimp were all good. Dinner was a personal pizza for each six of us. Mine was a white clam pizza, my husband ordered a burrata,basil and Parmesan, others were mozzerella prosciutto and others. All were excellent. Music was loud, but not crazy…we will be back again.