Papa Joe's Pizzeria - Honeoye

Her pizza was excellent, and everyone enjoyed the crust. The wings didn't appear to be medium, but the heat level was just right. We requested them to be crispy, and while they didn't turn out as crispy as we had hoped, they were still tasty.

2 hours and 25 minutes. Still waiting for our large pizza. Called after an 1 hr and 45 minutes…“It’s on its way…” sure it is…this is why Honeoye cannot succeed. We were told 35 minutes. At least be honest. Update…they never sent the pizza. Shocker.

OWNER IS THE NASTIEST PERSON PLACE IS SO DIRTY, WORKERS ARE HORRIBLE AND YOULL WAIT 2 HOURS FOR A MEDIOCRE PIZZA. is the worst business ever. There aren’t many options in this town but I still would never give this place my money again.

Pretty disappointing… first time getting this place. Got 2 pizzas, 3 dozen wings and a desert. $90 worth of food. Pizzas were okay, wings over cooked and barley any sauce. These fried dough sticks were dreadful. So thin and dry with no flavor. Tried to call about them and the guy on the phone was rude. Said they were busy and just put the food out so I should understand that. I would of waited longer to get good quality food…

The gluten-free pizza was outstanding, and the regular pizza was equally fantastic. The wings were crispy and full of flavor.