Hilo Pizza Company

Went to restaurant after viewing online. Took granddaughter and she had slices of pizza and I had a six inch Philly steak and ordered a footlong to go. According to online info, six inch was $9.75 and footlong was $13.75. I was told they didn’t sell footlong and I would have to take two six inch which I did. I was charged for two six inch sandwiches to go and not one footlong. I tried to check menu online today and get the message that the menu is wrong and is being updated. I think I should have been charged $13.75 for the footlong and not $19.50 for two six inch sandwiches!

First off no complaints on service, cleanliness and there very nice. Now onto the review, coming from Hawaii i never had a real new York Pizza, so I had to try it. The crust is chewy yet soft kinda made me think it needed to be cooked a little more) , the toppings are a little sparse, I had to add pepperoni and olives to there scicchitanos special, cheese is great but the pie had little or no sauce which made It a little bland for me. If this is what new York pizza is like I pass. 1 Pizza w 2 extra toppings cost $33dollars, wouldnt be a problem if the pie was amazing like the reviews said, but I feel just my opinion) that costcos makes a way better Pizza for 10 bucks lol hope this helps

My wife and I recently visited Hilo Pizza Co and had a wonderful experience. We ordered the Chicken Pesto pizza along with two beers. The service was impressively fast, and the pizza was absolutely delicious. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal and will definitely be coming back!

Came here after a beach day for a crowd-pleasing dinner and had a great pizza. Thin crust, crispy bottom, chewy crust, fresh toppings. We had a half pepperoni half Garlic Power. Be advised: the photo on the wall is NOT Lil' Smokey's in a delicious tomato sauce...it is tomatoes in a tomato sauce.

Stopped here on our way back from visiting the volcano national park. It did NOT disappoint. The pizza was delicious and the service was great. It has a “hole in the wall” vibe but don’t let it fool you. Would highly recommend eating here if you’re in Hilo!