Zur Herrenmuehle - Heidelberg

This restaurant was recommended by our accommodation and we are so glad that we were looking for it. it is located in a quiet opposite on a back road, away from the crowded roads in the old town. our waiter and the rest of the staff were attentive and we found the food delicious and beautifully presented. will not hesitate to return!

The food and service were good, nothing amazing though. The place is trying really hard at being a fine dining establishment but it honestly fits more to being a typical german diner. Overpriced in my opinion. However the summer garden's ambience is really nice.

The food was good, but not up to the price. The service needs to improve substantially.

The place get's three stars from me, because they fall short of what they strive to be. The service was nice, the place was beautiful, and the food was good. However, I expect more from the food at a place that advertises itself as a place of high cuisine. There was nothing wrong per se, but it seemed no better than many other places in town, which charge half the price. I will gladly pay a premium for premium food, but I think they need to do more to put themselves above the competition. Will gladly give them another chance in the future.

Reading the response to my wife's review of the service provided at your restaurant I was struck by the your patronising tone . It speaks volumes. We were served by a waiter that had difficulty hiding his irritation with us , your job as it were would be simply to apologise. Your response is quite bizarre in suggesting our perception of the poor service in your establishment was down to us having a bad day . No doubt you get complaints that are unjustified but this was the first time that I am aware of that my wife has left a complaint ,she has contrary to your insinuation eaten in more international level restaurant than she would care to remember. We are not fussy people we just simply require that we are not treated like interlopers at a private function, your rather long justification for the experience we had at your restaurant with its micro aggressive tone is simply a continuation of an unpleasant evening. If it wasn't for the second waiter who took over we would have left . I certainly will not be returning.