Old Greenwalls - Grand Island

I give this place 5 stars all day! is it the best? Maybe not, but it is quite good and the amount of food for which is amazing! chargrilled wings are my favorite! pizza is also really good and they have great combo offers! btw, if they ever want fried teig, if there is no karneval or fair around, that is the place to go! holy kuh so good and so big! I tried the fish for the first time tonight. not bad, I prefer to break it, but that was a generous part. with good taste. coleslaw was also decent, with a spicy bite. employees are always super nice, jacob has always gone beyond and beyond! I apologize for the dark pictures, my battery was too low. highly recommended! P.s my children say they have the best milkshakes if they ever get up and run for the season. I have a picture of fried teig, but it is not uploaded.

Chicken from garlauch finger are the best! Youngs work are always friendly and polite, even if they are busy! for some time, we have been more frequent. Chicken finger salat they are never with the amount, pizza logs they always give decent amount of marinara sauce! for a small restaurant they take care of the customers and always give 100% never had a problem placed with any order.

Would give it a half star if I could. Used to order from them every time I had people come to Niagara Falls to see sites and relax, because the sweet spicy sauce WAS to die for but tonights was our last order from there ever. Have literally ordered dozens of times, but a month ago, got chicken fingers order that was full gristle but figured maybe they ran out and had to buy other. Tonight's order not only had gristle big enough that I couldn't swallow it, it hurt my tooth when I bit it. I put that piece of chicken back on the plate, the gristle in a napkin and tried the next finger and bit into a bone. Took it to kitchen to pull it out and it was over an inch long. Drove it back to the Old Greenwalls, asked the cook that always does that great sauce for the owner. He agreed and turned back to the person who had some out of a room behind him, took one look at me and told the worker no. The cook turned back to me and said the owner wasn't there. But the tall owner stood there and watched the interaction between us as I showed the young man the big piece of gristle that hurt my tooth, then the bone which I showed him was tough as I put it Through the styrofoam. He didn't offer to make it right, or replace the food, so I took my plate out of the styrofoam, slid the chicken off of it while asking if they'd started using different chicken. The cook did say he was sorry while I just stood there, waiting to find out if they were doing something different, but he said they'd not switched brands and that they weren't responsible for something inside food they'd prepared. Realized I was not ever going to try that food again. I wasn't angry, just sad, as that was some great sauce and not even on the menu, but I'm done. Small business or not, it's not worth breaking a tooth.

Lost a loyal customer around last year because the food Is grease soaked lately. it’s sad I can expect a stomach ache if I eat it, maybe time to clean the fryer out

A local pizzeria gem tucked alongside the cayuga creek in the LaSalle section of town. Their food is done the true WNY way and it is delicious. From Pizza to wings to subs and appetizers/fingerfoods it's all made with quality and all made to order. A small dining room and some quaint creekside tables allow you to eat on site, and they even have a walk up window to do your ordering from if you like. A place that's tucked away and easy to miss, but you'll be the one missing out should you not sample their wares.