New York Vinny's Pizza - Federal Way

I used to give this restaurant a higher rating until they discontinued their $8.99 deal, which was the best part. Now, the prices are a bit high for a medium-sized pizza that looks like a large. Unfortunately, I have to admit that I will be going to Domino's for their two for $6.99 deal if I want a cheap and quick pizza now.

Unfortunately, on 3-17 and 3-19, the same male staff member at Vinny's attempted to add his own tip to my purchase without my consent, claiming it was a glitch. Then, on the second occasion, myself and my mother became sick after it was discovered that dish soap had been added to our pizza. This was not food poisoning or an allergic reaction, but a deliberate poisoning by Vinny's staff. I have no idea why this occurred, and I am concerned that the management will not address this ongoing issue. I have experienced negative interactions with the local police and have faced harassment from the staff at Vinny's, including drive-by incidents and false information being given about my address. Even though I attempted to address these issues with a manager, I have not seen any resolution. The fact that the cashier responsible for robbing customers is still employed is troubling. I caution others against patronizing Vinny's as long as the owner allows this behavior to continue. I fear that if this behavior is not stopped, it may escalate to the use of more dangerous chemicals in customers' food.

The food is okay, but I'm not planning on returning after paying $15 for one large grab-and-go pepperoni pizza that used to cost $8. Domino's and Pizza Hut are more affordable options.

The pizza at this place is great, but they recently got rid of the grab-and-go option. It doesn't really make sense to come here when there are other pizza places nearby that are just as good and cheaper (Little Caesar's is right next door). Please bring back the grab-and-go pizza option. I understand inflation is high, but it would still be much appreciated.

Vinny's is one of our favorite go-to restaurants. It has a NY-style pizza with a foldable crust that we enjoy, as it's not too crunchy. Our preference is to order something custom-made rather than the grab-and-go options. We like to add extra sauce and have it baked hot and fresh. The XXL deals are priced excellently. In conclusion, the pizza at Vinny's is great and we absolutely love it.