New York Bagel Deli - Erie

Great freshly made bagels! Love the variety of bagels to choose from. We love to stop here after our morning bike ride around Presque Isle for the breakfast sandwich. Great reward!

Always friendly and their bagels are amazing..So many different flavors to choose from..

Great family owned feel!The best bagels ever!My favorite is the BLT on three cheese garlic bagel …. Yummy!

I had my first experience at this bagel shop today, and I was surprised to find that the prices were significantly higher than what was listed on their website. I ordered a garlic bagel breakfast sandwich, but all of the garlic was burnt and had to be scraped off. The same issue occurred with the two everything bagel breakfast sandwiches I ordered. I’m quite unlikely to return. Also, just a heads up, they added a 4% administrative fee to my bill—what is that about?

I visited this bagel shop for the first time today, and I have to say I was quite surprised by the prices—they were significantly higher than what was listed on their website. I ordered a garlic bagel breakfast sandwich, but unfortunately, the garlic was burnt and had to be scraped off. The same issue occurred with the two everything bagel breakfast sandwiches I ordered. I probably won’t come back. Also, just a heads up: they charged an additional 4% administrative fee, which I found puzzling.