Pizza Pantry - Ellettsville

We absolutely loved this place until they got our order wrong and lied about fixing the problem. We are vegetarians and always order meatless pizzas. This night was no different. One of the two pizzas had pepperoni on it and we immediately called to get the order corrected. We were told that the easiest way would be to credit our credit card. We offered to wait for another pizza, but were told the best thing would be a refund to the credit card used. Logged in to the bank and noticed that did not take place. Called and had to wait for a call back. Then they pretended not to remember the incident. After reminding them again, we were told that our only option was to get a free pizza, but we would have to pay for the delivery. I just told them to forget it. Will NEVER order again.

I've been ordering from here for as long as I can remember. Sausage and pepperoni thin crust pizza is the way to go. It's delicious and it never takes them more than 20 minute to have your order ready!

Ordered the stromboli and the basket of fried mushrooms and was honestly not expecting much but was proven very wrong, to my pleasure. The stromboli was traditional served with bread and butter pickles which is a must! I must say though the fried mushrooms stole the show! They were fresh and breaded ever so lightly which is the way they should be. No heavy batter that takes away from the mushroom. These were honestly top 3 fried mushrooms I've had. I will definitely be back for those! Diamond in the rough!

We love their sausage pizza and roasted mushrooms. that's a way for us when we're in the opposite.

The taste of eating is excellent, but on the sandwiches there are hardly any beats. Try again.