Red Horse Market - East Hampton

This store used to be an organized place with a variety of items, and you could always find everything. Not only that, but the owners made sure to respect the line that was always formed next to the salad bar. Where are the managers of this place now? Two weeks ago, I bought some fish, and it came with worms. The lady at the counter only refunded me for the weight of the fish, which was much less than what I had brought (considering the first portion). A Native American gentleman didn't know what to do or say, claiming to be the owner, but he doesn't seem to know his business. They are terrible.

Great store! They sell New York’s Favorite Coffee. It’s the best coffee there is.

Whole family is a scammer. Daughter scammed me for my money and blocked me and when I told her mom, she blocked me to. Scamming family who is poor found this in the bio of their instagram profile they scammed me on

Best pies anywhere. Prepared food at the Red Horse is great. The baked clams, empanadas, salads are all top notch. Though it’s hard to walk out of there without spending at least $100 every time. I realize it’s the Hamptons, but prices are still a bit high. Not the best spot for groceries, definitely worth it for the prepared foods.

It's like Cheers..... everyone remembers your name. Absolutely wonderful staff and outstanding food. You can't do better in the area.