The Frisky Oyster - Dering Harbor

Great meal! Beautiful atmosphere! Friendly service!

Fresh and delicious oysters. Caesar salad with anchovies is flavorful. Cauliflower quinoa cake and scallop with risotto are also quite good and worth a try. Service is friendly and attentive, albeit a little slow due to completely full restaurant. Reasonably priced wines.

Always an amazing experience. The food, service and drinks are exceptional. If you’re in the Greenport area, I highly suggest.

I’m giving the restaurant a 2 star rating because although the food was good, the server disappeared and never came back ruining the experience. We’d give it one star, but because the food was delicious, I had to bump it up a star. After getting our drinks, the server never came back to our table and we never saw her in the dining room again. After getting our entrees and finishing eating, the man bussing our table asked if we wanted to see a dessert menu. Once we got that, we sat for 30 minutes without anybody coming to check if we wanted anything. Another server saw us looking around and she brought our check. After waiting another 10 minutes visibly looking around, that other server finally came back to close out our bill. Horrible experience. For the price we paid, that is not the service we expected. As for the food drinks… we recommend the Shineapple Express Pink Panther if you like sweeter drinks. The grilled Caesar salad was OK, but not our favorite. The Lobster Gigli pasta was delicious and so was the Pomegranate BBQ Short Ribs (sweet/fruity BBQ flavor).

Best restaurant I’ve been to on Long Island. Service was amazing. Menu is very unique