Caffe Italia - Deer Park

Absolutely the best homemade fresh gelato! They offer their signature flavors alongside exciting new options; for instance, today they featured rainbow cookie gelato. Their tiramisu is exceptional, and the biscotti and other desserts are fantastic as well. Cafe Italia truly feels like a little slice of Italy. There’s both indoor and outdoor seating available. I highly recommend checking them out if you haven't yet. The staff is always friendly!

The cappuccino is fantastic, and the tiramisu is delicious. The lady who prepares and serves them is incredibly nice and friendly. While we were there, a man came in who appeared to be the owner, but he didn't seem very approachable. However, it seems that he doesn't interact much with the customers.

This place offers the best gelato and coffee on the Island. My favorite gelato flavors are the Tiramisu (which includes ladyfingers), Amarena, and Wildberries Mascarpone. The espresso is rich and smooth. The customer service is excellent, and there are plenty of regular patrons.

Great place for Italian ice cream on long island. I love their hazelnut and pistachio flavors. I and my kids stop here a couple of times every month.

Absolutely amazing. Got a chance to visit Italy with my wife this year and after trying Italian gelato we were hooked. We couldn?t get enough of it so upon our arrival we decided to google gelato near us and lo an behold we found this place. It is absolutely amazing. Taste just like the one we had in Italy. Quality stuff!!!