Papa Luigi's - Cudahy

The pizza and pasta with marinara sauce were exceptional. The only feedback I have is that we ordered root beer and it came with too much ice. Root beer should be served without ice, so remember to specify your preference. The delivery driver was friendly and arrived right on time, letting us know when he was on his way.

The Fettuccine Alfredo is not worth the price nor the flavor. The only thing that was actually worth ordering was the pizza. Definitely way over priced for ok pasta

I am disappointed in this order. There is basically no meat on the lasagna and did not come with garlic bread. I have ordered it in the past and it was so much better. In the past, it was amazingly good.

I am originally from Rockford, IL and although I don't miss it there, I do miss the pizza places. This restaurant in Milwaukee serves the exact kind of pizza I love! I am thrilled to have found a place that reminds me of my childhood. The food here is truly amazing.

I tried this restaurant for the first time today on a cold day when we weren't sure what would be open. Papa Luigi's came through! We ordered the 14" Papa's Deluxe with fresh mushrooms and it was delicious. We also decided to try a meatball on the side, and it had a great flavor and texture. Lastly, we ordered the Jalapeno Poppers with cream cheese, and they were also a hit. Overall, we were pleasantly surprised and our stomachs are satisfied!