Castaways Pizza And Grill - Conneaut

One of Conneaut's hidden gems. The pizza and wings, especially the peach flavor, are the best in town!

I went for lunch with my husband, children, and niece and nephew. We found great deals on my husband and children's two pizzas, and my salad was amazing. However, my nephew's chicken tasted like it was fried in old oil, so we had to send it back. Fortunately, the staff was very attentive to our concerns and handled everything politely, making sure to rectify the situation. Overall, it was a pleasant first experience!

Castaways offers a wonderfully friendly atmosphere. Our waitress, Lisa, was fantastic—her positive demeanor really made us feel welcome. The calzone we ordered was delicious, filled with a variety of flavorful cheeses that really made each bite enjoyable. We opted for the 12-inch rolling zone to share, and it was so generous that we had to take half of it home. With great prices, tasty food, and a lovely ambiance, this place is definitely worth a visit.

Definitely my new place, was in this district 3 years and every week I go out and try what our local restaurants offer, my biggest beep is the wing if you can't cook them as I order them, then continue to the next restaurant. I definitely give this place 10 stars from the 5 Google gives you the opportunity. Very friendly environment among guests and Ashley ensured that everything was fine....!!!!

Visited with my family for dinner. Pizza was very good. Chicken Parm sandwich was gigantic. Service was fast and friendly. Glad we stopped.