Old Chicago Pizza Taproom

I'm feeling a bit disappointed, to be honest. I don't visit often, but whenever I do, I always order the Chicago Fire Calzone. Tonight, we decided to share that, while the kids ordered their own meals. My daughter absolutely loved the Marinara Chicken, and my son had a kids' meal, but unfortunately, they forgot his drink. I was really looking forward to enjoying the Chicago Fire with my husband, but when we cut it open, everything inside had turned into a texture that resembled paste. We'll eat it since it was quite expensive, but I truly hope this isn't the new standard for the Calzone at Old Chicago.

Overall, the service was better than average! Our appetizer did get overlooked, but the entrees were delicious—my burger was juicy and cooked exactly as I requested. They also had Mellow Yellow, which was a nice surprise! In the future, I might consider curbside pickup if I decide to eat here again.

Absolutely fantastic food and exceptional service! (Just a note for management... the wonderful waitress wears a scarf on her head.) We visited for a relaxing dinner while watching the Chiefs game. It was my first time dining there, and it turned out to be a wonderful experience. I was pleased to see they offer gluten-free pizza, but I just couldn’t get myself to try the cauliflower crust—it really tastes like cauliflower. I much prefer a rice-based option.

Grabbed a pizza after an Air Force football game (we beat CU and was super impressed with Bill the manager and Molly our server. They really wanted to make sure our visit was perfect. We ordered the Chicago 7 and it was awesome. We even got a cookie pizza to finish off the meal. Loved it!!!

I was really disappointed. Short staffed and only one server for all the tables outside the bar. She was insanely busy and just couldn’t give quality customer service. No drink refills offered. Never asked if we wanted dessert (we did). And to top things off, son woke up in the middle of the night to terrible abdominal cramps and diarrhea. He ate a completely different calzone than me with different ingredients. Symptoms sure are mimicking food poisoning. We won’t be back.