Pizza Man - Coleman

One of the best crusts i’ve ever experienced. Seriously top top tier stuff coming out of this place. I am a person who has flown to NYC just to get pizza.

Thin perfect crisp to the crust. Delicious sauce.Will have again.

I wish I had taken a picture of that pizza. We've been getting pizza at Pizza man's for probably 30 years. It came under new ownership a few months ago, and I had a bunch of family in town so we decided to give it a try. Not one person had anything good to say about that pizza. We requested well done, with five items. It was barely done at all, the crust was so thin I bet it wasn't an eighth of an inch thick. You could not pick up a piece of pizza because it was like a wet noodle. The first thing you get though is when you open the box and you see that the toppings are all at the center, there's a good 2-in ring around the outside that has no toppings at all except for the cheese. Very sad, as they had historically been a wonderful place that was local for us.

We've been getting pizza from Pizza Man for probably 30 years or close to it. Never had a complaint. Now it's under new ownership, and I am so sad. We ordered a five item pizza and requested that it be well done. Not only was it not well done, but it was pretty close to undercooked. There was no Browning on the top at all, almost like the cheese was barely melted. The crust was so thin you can almost see through it, there's no way it could support being picked up it was like a wet noodle. My husband refuses to eat it if I order it again, which I really don't want to do anyway. So sad because Steve's crew made a phenomenal Pizza.

Great food! I had the calzone and it was delicious! A little pricey, but it’s big enough for me to have leftovers :