Cassie's Supper Club - Cody

Absolutely amazing! My steak was cooked perfectly, and my wife's shrimp was just as impressive. The dinner salad was fresh and crispy, and the side dishes were superb. The service was spot on—I received just the right amount of attention from my server to ensure we had everything we needed, without being intrusive. The prices were quite reasonable, especially given the high cost of beef these days!

I had a disappointing experience at this restaurant. The steak was tough, and the baked potato was undercooked. We waited more than an hour for our food, which was also quite expensive. I don't plan on coming back. How hard can it be to cook a steak and a potato? It was frustrating to notice that we weren't the only guests expressing complaints.

Some reviews and the restaurant itself claim to serve the best steak in Wyoming. If this is truly the best, Wyoming might want to rethink its cattle industry. We sampled the filets at $42 each, but they weren't the most tender and had a few tough spots. The service was underwhelming; our waitress seemed overwhelmed and often absent. I even had to go to the bar to get my own beer because she was hard to track down. As for the Yellowstone cheesecake—definitely give that a miss! Overall, it felt like a $40 meal ended up costing us $135.00.