Little Pie Company - City of New York

Our son moved to NYC was away from friends family for his birthday. His favorite dessert is pie. Thank goodness for the Little Pie Company. It was so easy to order on the website choose the delivery day time. Super impressed with how much care was shown for our order. Thanks Little Pie Company!

I’ve been a few times and have tried several things and have never been wowed. The mud cake isn’t too sweet so that’s one of the better options considering mud cakes are usually ridiculously sweet. On the other end, the Key Lime pie, one of my absolutely favorite deserts, is one of the worst. It’s uninspired, bland, looks sad and the crust is meh in a cheap aluminum foil tin. I’ve had a decent chocolate chip cookie here and a ordinary brownie, but all in all, I’m not sure if I’d go in at all if it wasn’t on my way home.

AMAZING pies and definitely worth the price point, I took my pie home and ate the next day and still was SUPER good! Must check this place out!!!

Outstanding …. Hands down every time I’m in New York City must make a stop here to pick up four or five pies. The pies are worth the pain later on in the gym……..

We’ve been buying pies from the Little Pie Company for 30+ years, and continue to go out of our way to do so. Their sour cream apple walnut pie may very well be the best apple pie in the world. Highly recommend!