Build Your Own Cookie

BYOC is an absolute dessert paradise! During our stay at Yogi Bear, which is just a three-minute drive away, we stumbled upon this gem. We spent about $35 for our family of five, and it was definitely worth it. My kids had a fantastic time personalizing their sundaes, choosing their cookies, ice cream, and toppings—it was a joy to see their enthusiasm! Personally, I thought the ice cream was the highlight, although the cookies were also delicious. If you’re in the mood for a fun and interactive dessert experience, BYOC is the perfect spot. It’s a hit with the kids and satisfying for parents, making it a win-win all around!

It may seem straightforward and easy to overlook, but this place truly stands out. It has become a favorite during our visits to the island. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Wow! Even though the line was long, it moved quickly. There were so many options to choose from. The salted caramel with butter pecan ice cream, hot fudge, and pretzels was amazing, and the milkshakes were delicious too. I highly recommend the banana pudding milkshake! I will definitely be going back.

Great place for a sweet treat! I got a chocolate chip cookie with sorbet and fresh strawberries. They have many options for cookies, ice cream, and toppings.

Great cookie and ice cream selection, and the quality and taste were outstanding. Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5