Menemsha Fish Market - CHILMARK

Not crowded in Sept., as in summer. Lobster was The Best! And fishing harbor ambience gorgeous and serene.

Popular place. Fresh catch seafood . No indoor dining. Eat outside and watch the boats and water.

Fish here is so fresh and they make my favorite bluefish pate

My wife and I both had the lobster bisque. It was amazing, very delicious, very filling Don't miss this place because there's a whole lot more to love. Lots of live lobsters and great fish. This is a wonderful restaurant.

Honestly, a little disappointed. The food is fresh, but if you plan to order a cold lobster roll, they are pre made and you get it yourself out of the fridge? We wanted something made to order so we ordered the hot butter lobster roll, almost seems like those are premade also and just put, bun and all, in the microwave. The bun was so soggy it was mush right when we unwrapped it, inedible. We are asked for a fresh roll and transferred the lobster meat into the new roll. To the raw bar side, ordered a dozen oysters, this isn’t anything that larsens did but I just feel like it should be said how large these oyster were, I’m talking filled your mouth and had to chew for a while huge. We also ended up not eating most of them. I remember coming here years ago and it was a really great experience. The past 2 years I just feel like they could do better.