Jimmy's Pizza - Centerport

Ordered take out, when I received the order from Seamless, they forgot the soda. Called restaurant, 1st person didn’t understand the situation. 2nd person stated they could bring me my soda I purchased, but would have to tip AGAIN bc it’s their driver not seamless. (I had already tipped, and paid a delivery fee)They blamed everything on the Seamless driver for not picking up the entire order (but they’re the ones that give it to him check he takes everything) and said they could only refund me, they would not deliver it. Then they hung up on me.

Best garlic knots iv ever had ate a whole 12 by myself !!!

This is one terrible place, I order 10 pies for a high school basketball team and ask for them to be delivered in between 6:45 and 7 pm and the guy came 25 minutes early when the basketball game goes until 6;45 and by the time the kids ate it was cold, I called to make a complaint and the girl at the counter was so rude and when I finally got the manager he was worse and literally told me to screw myself after I paid $200 including tip for 10 pies.

I like the regular slice here, and here's a little secret-probably the best pizza in the Northport/Centerport area.

Cheese Pizza not very good, salads always swimming in dressing and pricing is whacked!! I try and give it a chance hoping it’s always gonna be better but! Sorry